ED 529 Opinion Paper One
In the article How to thrive--not just survive--in a one-computer classroom, Chaika provides numerous strategies to manage a one-computer classroom. Several issues presented in the article left me with a negative opinion of the article.
In reading this article, I quickly came to the conclusion that the article is geared towards an elementary classroom. No direct mention is made to that affect, but none of the “experts” who are quoted taught in middle or high schools. As a middle school teacher, I find it helpful to have strategies and examples provided by other teachers who face the same issues in the classroom that I face. I did not find any suggestions that were geared toward a middle school or high school classroom.
Many of the suggestions given by Chaika would not work in the middle school or high school setting due to the difference in time available due to scheduling as well as the number of students taught by the teacher. Elementary teachers have a fixed number of students the entire day so the scheduling suggestions might work in that setting but they were not appropriate for 50 minute periods with 25 students per class.
The age of the article was also a drawback in my opinion. Much has changed in the way of technology in the last 10 years. I need to use my computer to present multimedia lessons and use resources like student response systems so the computer would not be available for student use during the class on most days.
In conclusion, the article did not provide me with any real useful information due to the audience for which it was written and the lack of relevance to my grade level.
M20008068
Dennis L. Engle ED 529 February 3, 2010
Reference Page
Chaika, G. (2005, December 20). How to thrive--not just survive--in a one-computer classroom. EducationWorld.com. Retrieved Friday, January 29, 2010, from http:// www.educationworld.com/a_tech/tech/tech092.shtml.
M20008068